Muddymoles mountain biking in the Surrey Hills and Mole Valley

On-one 456 Ti (titanium) review

Posted by Lloyd | March 2, 2011 | 6 comments so far

I decided I wanted a trail hardtail as an alternate ride experience to the Trek EX9. After some research I decided on the titanium On-One 456 as it had great reviews and it looked good (yes I am that shallow).

The Lynksy-made Ti is no longer in production and after months of looking I never saw a large one come up on ebay so I took the plunge and put in an order for the first of the new design Van Nicholas made frames.

On One 456 titanium by Van Nicholas

In October my shiny new 20” frame arrived and it went to Mark at BikeTech to be built up. It was built up from a 2006 Stumpjumper Pro I bought a year earlier. New bits were a Hope tapered headset and Fox Float 140mm forks.

From the Pro came a full 2006 XTR groupset (hubs, wheels, cranks, pedals, brakes, gears) and ‘unusual’ xlite stem. The complate bike weighs in at between 23-24 pounds. Other tech bits are that it has swap dropouts so can be run as a singlespeed or with a bolt through axle.

Much like food, enjoyment is as much in the appearance as the taste. The On-One looks fantastic with its brushed titanium tubes. The joins are very clean and neat; it is a beautiful and beautifully made bike. So far so good.

I am a long limbed 6’3 and the 20” frame with a layback seatpost is just perfect for comfortable long rides.

So what is it like to ride? Well given its light weight it is surprisingly better going down than up. While it is certainly a very good climber given its weight, with a slack head angle and long travel forks it is not a race machine. However, downhill it is simply amazing.

I do not know how it does it but it feels like a FS bike downhill, so well does it stick to the trail. It is very stable and holds the line well and when it does get bumped or knocked the reactions are very light and fast. I feel more in control at speed downhill than on the EX9, which itself is very, very good.

I have ridden most of the local trails on both bikes and cannot think of any places where I would favour the EX over the 456 and if I could choose just one bike to keep it would be the On-One 456 Ti without any reservation (although I am lucky not to have to choose).

It is very versatile, you could put 80 or 100mm XC forks and with a high end groupset and race wheels you would have a superlight race machine, but with 140-160mm forks and a hardier group and wheelset you have a rugged trail bike, and all flavours inbetween.

I am sure the professionals will be testing it soon and I look forward to seeing what they think, but for me it is all the bike I need (but not necessarily want!)

Filed under Bikes, Reviews in March 2011


About the author

There are 6 comments on ‘On-one 456 Ti (titanium) review’

We love to get comments from our readers - if you've spent a few moments to comment, thank-you.

If you haven't had a chance yet, jump to our comments form if you have something to say.

  1. Tony says:

    Blimey Lloyd you avatar pic does you no favours – heavy night out was it.

    I know what you mean about being overbiked for alot of trails in Surrey with the Fuel Ex8. However when you get to a rocky trail centre a full susser comes into it’s own. I’ve ridden back to back W2W rides on HT & FS at Afan and I know which I prefer.

    Nice understated build too – BikeTech Mark doing his magic!

  2. pij says:

    …go watch the Ragley video of Ed…

  3. mike61 says:


    I have had one of the original 456ti’s for 3 years and agree with everything said here.

    I will never sell it, it’s the best bike I have ever owned and I love it!


  4. chris says:

    what stem is that! very nice and i have never seen anything like it

    • Lloyd Brown says:

      Hi Chris, it is an x-lite stem. It came with another bike I bought on ebay so I don’t know where it came from or when (although the previous bike was built up in 2006/7). I have never seen anything similar but I love the look and it suits the rest of the bike. Bling – tastic

      • chris says:

        thanks for the quick comment – as i thought by the looks – this is an old company/stem from the UK that is no longer making parts (havent for many years). there are currently no top loading, 25.4, longer than 55mm stems out there – this is a perfect fit. ill be on the lookout! thanks for the quick response and very nice bike!

Leave a comment…

Have your say – we'd love to hear what you think.

If you have something to add, just complete this comment form (we will not publish your email address).

*Required information.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.